Episode 12 with Marc Spurling

The EV Insurance Challenge: Why Are Premiums So High?

‍

Electric vehicles are transforming the automotive landscape, but fleet managers face a significant hurdle: insurance premiums up to 25% higher than conventional vehicles. Our latest Auto Futurecast episode dives deep into these challenges with Marc Spurling from Aon, revealing why costs are rising and how smart fleet managers are adapting.

‍

‍

Understanding the Insurance Premium Gap

The insurance industry grapples with what Aon identifies as "four megatrends": weather, technology, trade, and people. For EVs specifically, this creates distinct challenges:

‍

Insufficient Claims History

Unlike internal combustion engines with decades of data, EVs lack comprehensive claims history. Combined with rapid technological evolution, insurers adopt cautious approaches, inflating premiums.

"Insurance companies depend on data to predict risks," Marc explains. "Limited data amplifies trends into perceived substantial risks."

‍

Complex Repair Requirements

Advanced EV technology complicates repairs significantly. Minor collisions can damage sophisticated sensors or LIDAR systems, requiring manufacturer-approved specialists who remain scarce. This drives repair costs and vehicle downtime, contributing to higher premiums.

‍

Technical Sophistication

Modern EVs function as computers on wheels. Previously straightforward repairs now demand intricate technical expertise, increasing both repair expenses and insurance costs.

‍

Beyond Vehicle Coverage: Infrastructure Risks

Fleet electrification introduces new risks beyond vehicle insurance that many managers overlook:

‍

Property Insurance Complications

Property insurers remain cautious about fire risks associated with EV charging, often imposing restrictions or premium increases. Businesses frequently encounter these obstacles only after beginning electrification, causing costly project delays.

‍

Infrastructure Demands

Installing multiple charging points can overwhelm building systems, whilst space requirements for safe installations are commonly underestimated, significantly impacting total costs.

‍

Innovative Approaches

Companies like First Bus demonstrate creative solutions, using multi-use charging hubs that leverage off-peak hours to charge additional vehicles and generate supplementary revenue.

‍

Data-Driven Insurance Evolution

Connected vehicle technology promised revolutionary pay-per-use models and real-time risk assessment. However, reality proves more complex.

‍

Refining Vehicle Data

Marc offers a fresh perspective: "Data is the new oil, but crude oil requires refinement to be useful, and data follows the same principle." Modern vehicles generate massive information volumes, yet only specific data points meaningfully predict risk.

‍

Beyond Simple Mileage

Early models relied heavily on mileage tracking, proving overly simplistic. Three miles in central London present different risks than three miles on rural motorways. Insurers now focus on behavioural data for more accurate risk assessment.

‍

Strategic Fleet Management Approaches

Forward-thinking fleet managers adopt structured methodologies to address insurance challenges:

‍

Early Implementation Benefits

Businesses already operating EV fleets report reduced maintenance costs, improved reliability, and gradually decreasing insurance premiums as risk profiles mature.

‍

Proactive Risk Strategy

High-performing managers collaborate with specialised brokers to develop tailored policies, highlighting proactive measures like driver training and vehicle monitoring for better terms.

‍

Infrastructure Coordination

Successful transitions involve early collaboration with property insurers and engineers to address power and space requirements before charging station installation.

‍

‍

Future Opportunities in Electric Fleet Management

Despite current obstacles, fleet electrification offers substantial long-term advantages:

‍

Battery Technology Progress

Improved battery chemistry reduces risks like catastrophic failures, which should eventually lower insurance premiums.

‍

Market Development

As insurers become more comfortable with personal EV risks, these trends are expected to extend to commercial fleets, stabilising premiums.

‍

Shared Infrastructure Networks

Collaborative charging infrastructure helps reduce range anxiety and improve asset utilisation whilst lowering upfront business investment.

‍

‍

Implementing Effective EV Insurance Strategies

Success requires sophisticated risk management approaches. The key lies in partnering with brokers who understand EV technology and its unique risks. Tailored policies reflecting specific operational needs, rather than standard EV loadings, prove essential.

‍

Most importantly, insurance should be viewed as a strategic enabler of electrification goals, not merely a compliance requirement. Businesses adopting this mindset will navigate change successfully and gain competitive advantages as markets mature.

‍

Discover More on Auto Futurecast

The electric revolution is here. Whilst insurance presents challenges, it's one of many transformation hurdles. Strategic understanding and planning enable fleet managers to thrive in the electric future.

‍

Don't miss our latest episode featuring Marc Spurling from Aon, where we explore these EV insurance challenges in detail. Listen now on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify, and join our automotive community on LinkedIn for more insights.

‍